Thursday, November 19, 2026
Newsletter About
Opinion

The Islands That Texas Wants From Mexico

Mexicans thought the border was settled. Then came an unexpected claim.

This article was originally published by The Atlantic and is republished here under license.

Despite all of the disagreements and misunderstandings between the United States and Mexico, the two countries, until recently, seemed to at least agree on how to locate their border. It had, after all, been a settled matter of international law for more than 170 years, since the end of the Mexican-American War and the U.S. purchase of New Mexico.

Then came an announcement late last month from Texas General Land Commissioner Dawn Buckingham. “I have a responsibility to protect every acre of state land,” she began. Buckingham went on to describe nine small, overgrown islands in the Rio Grande between the U.S. and Mexico, whose ownership, she wrote, had been “uncertain.” Her office, after being contacted by U.S. Customs and Border Protection, determined that the islands belonged to Texas. Buckingham said that the “strategically located lands”—roughly 66 acres in total—would soon be “accessed, monitored, and protected” by state and federal authorities. It seemed that the border was going to shift once again.

Mexican officials, still trying to navigate the Trump administration’s periodic threats of an air strike, suddenly needed to take on a question that they thought had been resolved since before Abraham Lincoln took office: the contours of their own nation. Befuddled diplomats consulted with Mexico’s president, Claudia Sheinbaum, who addressed the issue at a press conference by suggesting that her nation’s northern neighbor was playing politics. “They are in the midst of elections and are claiming that these islands are now part of Texas,” she said. “But they are not.”

[Read: The schism within the Trump administration on Mexico]

The Rio Grande islands—several dozen of them in total—have for years been an annoyance to members of the U.S. Border Patrol, who believe that human smugglers and drug traffickers use them as waypoints. Armed prison escapees from Mexico once hid on one of the islands; Mexican soldiers raided a “narco camp” on another; Border Patrol agents once rescued an 11-year-old Salvadoran girl from one. The dots of land are covered in long stalks of carrizo cane that gave criminal spotters a hidden vantage point for surveilling the border. Some used them to stash packages of cocaine.

Rudy Karisch, a former chief of the Border Patrol’s Rio Grande Valley sector, remembers seeing the islands for the first time and puzzling over what to do about the unexpected nuisance. “The first thing I thought was, Why can’t we dredge them out and get rid of them?,” he told me.

It hasn’t been that simple. The islands were formed over years as the Rio Grande, like all rivers, moved sediment and carved a new course. In 1848’s Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, the two nations agreed that the border would remain in “the middle of that river, following the deepest channel.” But as the river moved, so did the border, periodically adding hundreds of acres to one country’s territory as it eroded the other’s. Sometimes, tracts of land disappeared under floodwaters. Those changes to the border could take years to resolve, but they were almost always handled amicably. Buckingham’s statement was different. It appeared to amount to a unilateral land grab.

The border’s original surveyors didn’t anticipate a shifting border. They didn’t care much for the border region at all. “Much of this country,” wrote Dr. Thomas Webb, one of the original border surveyors, “is a sterile waste, utterly worthless for any purpose than to constitute a barrier or natural line of demarcation between two neighboring nations.”

But as the border became more important and surveyors became more precise, both countries began paying more attention to where the actual line was. In the 1880s, the U.S. and Mexico clashed over the ownership of 20-acre Beaver Island, just southeast of Roma, Texas. In 1889, the International Boundary Commission was formed to resolve future disputes; it was later renamed the International Boundary and Water Commission as it monitored the flows of binational rivers. In the 20th century, land shifted back and forth between the two nations, usually without major concerns from officials in Washington or Mexico City.

The most recent time Americans unilaterally claimed territory across the border was in the 19th century. Now more than $1 million in freight crosses the border every minute. Mexican and American policy makers and intellectuals have long suggested that that entwined commercial relationship would lead to a more peaceful politics. In the Donald Trump era, that hasn’t always felt true.

By the time Buckingham, a physician from Austin, took over the Texas General Land Office in 2023, the border was one of the most monitored, patrolled, and highly secured stretches of rural land in the world. It was also at the center of state and national political campaigns. She decided that it would be a top priority of her tenure. In October 2025, Buckingham received a request from U.S. Customs and Border Protection, which asked her to review 28 islands along the Rio Grande “whose ownership had not been definitively established,” she told me. “The request brought an important issue to our attention,” she said. “When ownership is unclear, it can create uncertainty about which country’s law-enforcement agencies have authority to access and operate on that property.” (CBP declined to comment.)

Buckingham has sometimes worn a red Make America Texas cap, and in 2024, she purchased 1,400 acres of border land on the state’s behalf that she suggested could be used for a facility to process deportees as part of the president’s mass-deportation campaign. On other occasions, however, she has pushed back against the Trump administration, arguing, for example, that a border wall is not necessary in the Big Bend region of West Texas. In late October, she shared satellite imagery of the nine islands that appeared to show that they were north of the midway point in the Rio Grande. Buckingham cited the images as evidence that the islands belong to the United States.

Buckingham told me that she is “not attempting to redraw the international boundary or replace the role of the IBWC. We are establishing the State of Texas’s ownership interest in property based on the records available to our agency.” But it’s unclear how claiming the island to be Texas property wouldn’t also change the international boundary, if the land isn’t already considered American.

Mexican officials have become accustomed to threats of unilateral action from U.S. officials. Trump told Mexico’s president during the first week of his first term that he might send U.S. troops across the border to hunt down Mexican cartels. Later, he ruminated about shooting migrants in the legs and adding snakes and alligators to existing border infrastructure.

[Read: What I saw in Sinaloa]

But even Trump hasn’t talked about reapportioning land along the border. The federal government had long resolved borderland and border-water disputes through the IBWC, the binational commission of diplomats and engineers that is based in El Paso and Ciudad Juárez. Even as friction mounted between the two countries periodically over the past century, technocrats have quietly worked to settle disputes and maintain bilateral relations, no matter the political moment. Buckingham’s announcement took Mexican members of the IBWC by surprise, one Mexican official told me. (U.S. representatives on the IBWC declined to comment.) In her statement, Buckingham said that law-enforcement agents would be able to “patrol, inspect and clear (the islands) of any illegal activity.” It’s unclear whether agents have already been dispatched. If they were sent to land that wasn’t formally part of the United States, it might boost border enforcement, but it could also violate a long-standing treaty between the two countries. “The way we have resolved these issues over land has worked the same way for 137 years,” one Mexican official told me. In an instant, that appeared to be changing.

To get to the border islands from, say, Houston, you would need to head south on U.S. 77 past the Sarita checkpoint, where Border Patrol agents man a stretch of highway, 85 miles north of the Rio Grande. You would have to pass through—or over—the border wall, which in many places sits hundreds of meters north of the river. You would need to walk the arid no-man’s-land between the wall and the river. You would then need to take a short swim. You would, effectively, need to cross multiple borders to get to the border that Buckingham has claimed.

As Mexico and the IBWC weighed how to respond to Buckingham’s claim over the islands, Texas politics were turned upside down. In a statewide rout of Republicans, Buckingham lost her election this month to a Democrat, Benjamin Flores. Now it will be Flores, a pig farmer raised in Mexico City, who will decide whether to pursue ownership of the islands. When I called Flores this week, he told me that he was puzzled by Buckingham’s claim. “To say that these islands belong to Texas now, without respect for a bilateral agreement, is pretty cavalier,” he said. “There’s a process to resolve these things, and I’ll respect the process.” Buckingham’s successor told me that he has questions about how Texas’s border acquisition came about and how much was spent on it. Flores said that he plans to look into the project with an eye for “waste, fraud, and abuse.”

But even as Texas politics has changed, the occupant of the White House hasn’t. Trump and his administration have not addressed the fate of the islands directly. But the president has taken to Truth Social lately to warn of the “Huge CARAVANS” that “are forming and beginning their illegal march through Mexico.” Days after the election, Trump promoted to White House chief of staff Stephen Miller, his longtime aide who has previously pushed to conduct strikes on Mexican cartels. Miller in recent months has been making frequent calls to the U.S. ambassador in Mexico City to complain about border-crossing numbers. But he also celebrates how the border has been “sealed,” recently reposting on X a video of a quiet stretch of the Rio Grande. It was filmed not far from the islands.

More in Opinion

View All →

Leave a Reply