
The preserved ruins of Pompeii and Herculaneum, entombed for millennia by the disastrous eruption of Mount Vesuvius in 79 CE, have, since excavations began in the mid-eighteenth century, been a goldmine of detail depicting day-to-day life in the Roman empire. A little too much detail, in fact. In 1819, when Francis I, heir to the Kingdom of the Two Sicilies, visited the newly unearthed artifacts at what is now the National Archaeological Museum in Naples, hoping to marvel at the frescoes, paintings and sculptures that had been hidden for nearly two thousand years, he was so mortified by the explicit nature of the Roman art that he promptly ordered much of it to be hidden away again.
The future monarch’s acute embarrassment marked the inception of the Neapolitan museum’s Gabinetto Segreto—“secret room”—which would go on to hide a myriad of artworks depicting every conceivable act of lovemaking between women, men, gender-ambiguous figures and even gods (not to mention swans and goats). This evidence of the ancient Romans’ uninhibited attitude to sexual fantasy, pleasure and diversity was so at odds with the prudish Christian mores that had come to dominate Europe millennia later, the powers that be decided the public was better off shielded from it, lest they be corrupted.
The story of Pompeii…reveals how pornography has long been the battleground on which morality and power and control are contested.
The erotic paintings and sculptures hidden in the Gabinetto Segreto would, for most of the following two centuries, remain accessible only to learned men carrying either permits detailing evidence of their high moral standing, or bribes. Fear of the defiling power of Roman fantasy ran so deep that the entrance to the room was, at one point, bricked up entirely. Apart from a brief window during the height of the sexual revolution, the “secret room” remained largely closed to the public until 2000. When it finally reopened, it was accompanied by educational texts, as the Gabinetto Segreto’s scientific curator Floriana Miele told me, that were meant to help visitors understand ancient Roman attitudes towards fertility, life and pleasure and prevent the works from being seen through our own era’s more crude perspective on the erotic.
After all, much of the art left behind by people in antiquity suggested that they had a “very different way of thinking about life and nature,” Miele said. But, as Christianity spread across Europe, attitudes began to shift. By the Middle Ages a distinct “attitude of prudish secrecy” had taken hold—a mindset that Miele said would prove particularly conducive to “prurient curiosity.” This is the mindset in which we remain stuck today, and it is partly responsible for the mess we’re now in. The story of Pompeii not only shows us how the definitions of the sexually acceptable and taboo have continued to change over time but reveals how pornography has long been the battleground on which morality and power and control are contested.
*
Perhaps precisely because it was forbidden, the erotic art of Pompeii and Herculaneum became highly influential to the Western understanding of pornography, even inspiring its first English-language dictionary definition. The word itself has ancient Greek roots—pornē, meaning prostitute, and graphien, meaning writing—and originally referred to texts or depictions related to sex work. But in 1864 Webster’s, an American dictionary, defined it as visual stimuli intended to elicit sexual desire—or, more specifically, “licentious painting […] examples of which exist in Pompeii.” Fueled by frenzied media interest in the Neapolitan excavations, the artifacts of Pompeii had effectively entered nineteenth-century pop culture. But choosing such an ancient reference to define pornography also allowed a kind of respectful distance and, perhaps, a feigned ignorance of the more contemporary erotic material in circulation at the time, from flagellation novels and clandestine memoirs to the explicit photographs and prints that were being passed discreetly across drawing rooms.
The erotic art of Europe was hardly unique. In China, chungonghua, rooted in Taoist ideas about the importance of cultivating sexual energy—a force believed to link pleasure, health and spiritual harmony—often portrayed lovers in elaborate, sensuous settings. Japanese shunga woodblock erotica favored close-ups of engorged sexual organs. And in India, millennia-old instruction on kama—or desire—inspired not only the Kama Sutra but the erotic sculptures and reliefs still commonly found in Hindu temples. Yet in these cultures, too, erotic expression has always been shaped—and often constrained—by shifts in power.
For centuries, the degree to which porn is visible in a society has given an indication of that society’s approach to bodies and pleasure, and also how authority responds to nonconformity. What happens when desire strays beyond sanctioned limits? The question has always been where to draw the line. In the late Middle Ages and early Renaissance these tensions surfaced even in Christian prayer books, where custom-ordered copies sometimes contained sexually explicit scenes in their margins. As long as erotic collections like these remained a private pleasure accessible only to the elite—books were luxury objects, and most households owned none—the Roman papacy was relatively relaxed about pornography’s potential to challenge the Church’s strict aversion to non-procreational sexual acts—even when they appeared in sacred books. This ended with the advent of the printing press, which transformed erotica from an indulgence of the privileged into a source of inspiration for an ever-growing share of the general public.
With each technological leap forwards…pornography has tested those limits, reviving the tension between our hunger for transgression and our fear of what it may unleash.
By the sixteenth century it wasn’t only Bibles that were being widely distributed across Europe. Sexual imagery was being produced and circulated even by one of the era’s most influential printmakers, Marcantonio Raimondi, best known for his collaboration with the painter Raphael and his role in the popularization of Renaissance art. But his work on I Modi, or, The Ways, a book of pornographic engravings also known as The Sixteen Pleasures, landed him in prison by direct order of the Pope, who also demanded that all copies of the book be destroyed.
Today, there are no known surviving copies of I Modi, which was eventually accompanied by sixteen (very) explicit sonnets. The papacy succeeded in suppressing the book itself, but, in a nod to the way in which technological progress makes gatekeeping increasingly difficult, the printing plates survived, and the engravings and verses live on, along with a dazzling abundance of printed erotica from the centuries that followed.
Perhaps surprisingly, when erotic filmmaking began, it did not initially cause the kind of sustained public controversy it would later attract. The very first surviving example of an erotic film, Le coucher de la mariée, was made in 1896. It features a newly-wed woman getting ready for her first night in the marital bed while her husband, anxious and giddy, waits on the other side of her dressing screen. It’s not just the year of production that makes this film special. It is also one of the few “blue movies” to have a named director: Albert Kirchner, who a year later would go on to film the first ever cinematic depiction of the life of Christ.
Its screening in Paris marked the coquettish kick-off of a form that would eventually take the world by storm, even if pornographic film would remain controversial and confined to the shadows for a long time. For much of its early history, the people behind and in front of the camera were unnamed, but several of the films survive. In El Satario, an Argentinian film of 1907, a group of frolicking women encounter a devilish satyr in a forest. In the 1910 German film Am Abend a woman is seen masturbating through a keyhole, before she is joined by her voyeur. And in the 1915 film A Free Ride, believed to have been shot in New Jersey, a man wealthy enough to own a car offers two women a lift, then the three take turns to secretly watch each other pee during a roadside break and embark on a ménage à trois.
In the decades that followed, pornographic filmmaking remained largely underground. But people continued to create, enjoy and critique pornography, just as they have throughout history. It is a form that has evolved continually over the ages, forcing generation after generation to redraw the line between curiosity and control. With each technological leap forwards—from the arrival of the printing press, then the moving image and, later, the internet—pornography has tested those limits, reviving the tension between our hunger for transgression and our fear of what it may unleash.
______________________________

From Guilty Pleasure: The Pornification of the Internet, the Economy, and Everything Else by Patricia Nilsson. Copyright © 2026. Available from Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
Leave a Reply