Pope Leo XIV is leading the Catholic Church during a period of extraordinary demographic change. A century ago, Europeans dominated the Church, representing some two-thirds of the world’s Catholics. Today, Latin America and Africa together make up a majority. As a result of this shift, influence within the Church is quickly being redistributed from the West to the global South, two regions with often-competing ideas about the faith.
As Leo emphasized on his landmark trip to South America this month, one of his principal goals is to keep the Church united. Maintaining unity has been a challenge for nearly every pontiff, but few of them have overseen a group of believers who are as far-flung and culturally diverse as the one he heads. Given his biography, Leo may be an ideal pope for the job. But he’ll have to bridge a set of divisions that are likely to intensify as the Church’s center of power continues to move.
In many ways, the Church’s demographic transformation was personified by Leo’s immediate predecessor, Pope Francis. In 2013, Jorge Mario Bergoglio of Argentina became the first pontiff from the global South. As pope, he paid special attention to migration, poverty, and climate change, focusing on the disproportionate burdens these issues placed on the developing world. He also emerged as one of the most prominent critics of the West, condemning capitalist excess and even challenging NATO.
[Read: Why Pope Francis isn’t with the West on Ukraine]
Leo, too, has embodied the Church’s transition from the West toward the South. He’s the first pope born in the United States, but his formative pastoral experience came in Peru, where he served as a priest and bishop for 20 years and, in 2015, became a citizen. “That act symbolized a bond that this people had been weaving into my life long before,” he recalled during his visit to Lima this month. “Today I understand how much of this land remains with me and how much of my own story also belongs to you.” The pope’s connection to Latin America will be an important asset to him now that the region accounts for more than 40 percent of Catholics, twice Europe’s share.
The global South’s growing representation has given it a stronger voice within the Church, and pastors there seem more and more unwilling to let Europe tell them what to do. Much of this resistance has come from Africa, the Church’s fastest-growing region, which Leo visited in April—the longest trip of his papacy until this month’s journey through South America.
In recent years, African bishops have criticized the Church’s “Eurocentric” agenda, which they felt imposed an overly liberal approach on certain social issues. At a Vatican synod in 2014, one German cardinal complained that merely discussing homosexuality with his African peers was “taboo” and therefore impossible. “They should not tell us too much what we have to do,” the cardinal said, a remark that prompted the African leaders to organize a separate meeting and come up with a unified response. Two years later, many African bishops condemned Francis’s efforts to allow divorced and remarried Catholics to receive Communion in limited circumstances. In 2024, they refused to implement a declaration by Francis that authorized formal blessings of people in same-sex unions.
During a synod held from 2021 to 2024, pastors from the Middle East, Asia, Africa, and Oceania repeatedly condemned efforts by Western leaders in the Church to push “niche issues” such as women’s ordination as priests and the relaxation of Church teaching on homosexuality. As Leo told me last year in his first sit-down interview as pope, a cardinal from the Middle East approached him during the synod and lamented that pastors in the West are “obsessed with sexuality.”
Like Francis, Leo has become one of the world’s leading advocates for the global South. In response to a question about migration during his return flight from Africa, he issued one of his most direct appeals on its behalf: “What is the global North doing to help the global South, or those countries where young people today cannot find a future and therefore dream of moving North?” the pope asked.
Leo has also become one of the loudest voices challenging the West, drawing the ire of some of America’s most powerful men. In my interview with Leo, he expressed concern about Elon Musk becoming the world’s first trillionaire, which prompted Musk to respond on X with a quote from the Gospel of Matthew: “Why do you see the speck in your neighbor’s eye, but do not notice the log in your own eye?” In September, the tech mogul Peter Thiel called the pope a “useful idiot” for the Chinese Communist Party because of his advocacy for stricter AI regulation. And most notable, President Trump lashed out at Leo in April when the pope condemned the Iran war.
[Peter Wehner: The American pope vs. the American president]
As part of his effort to restore U.S. dominance in Latin America, Trump has tried to curtail migration—another source of tension between the president and the pope. Thanks to the region’s swing to the right, Trump has found many leaders there who are sympathetic with him on the issue. Leo met with one of them this month in Argentina: President Javier Milei, who has courted Trump’s favor by offering his nation as a haven for data centers. Local Catholic leaders have criticized Milei, especially over his austere economic policies, which led some observers to expect that his meeting with Leo would be tense. But Milei became tearful as he said goodbye to the pope, a likely sign of how much influence Leo’s voice carries in the region, where he drew the largest crowds of any event he’s held, in Rome or abroad.
Throughout his travels, Leo has appealed to the Catholic roots shared by both secular European societies, such as Spain and France, and Latin America, where the faith remains culturally prominent but Mass attendance is falling. Last week in Argentina, Leo pointed to that shared heritage as a means of “learning to live together, even amid differences of opinion.”
This lingering cultural faith has been essential in Leo’s efforts to keep the Church united. But secularization is depleting its supply. As the Church’s demographics continue to change—and as its priorities change with them—Leo’s successors may have to find another source of unity.
Leave a Reply