Monday, November 16, 2026
Newsletter About
Books

Curtis Sittenfeld’s Prep is coming to the small screen. Who should play Lee?

Back in 2005, Curtis Sittenfeld’s debut novel Prep was the talk of the town. We debated everything from its genre to its striving protagonist, whose moral universe felt like something straight outta Wharton. Sittenfeld was praised and derided for her

This article was originally published by Literary Hub and is republished here under license.

prep casting

Back in 2005, Curtis Sittenfeld’s debut novel Prep was the talk of the town. We debated everything from its genre to its striving protagonist, whose moral universe felt like something straight outta Wharton. Sittenfeld was praised and derided for her frankness about class and adolescent sex.

21 years later, this ur-Millennial text has finally gotten a green-light from Hollywood. A buzzy new adaptation helmed by the One Day team is coming soon to a Netflix near you—but we don’t yet have the skinny on casting. Which is where I come in.

The benefit of being a reader moonlighting in theatre is a certain—if I do say so myself—knack for casting. Here are some terrific young actors working today who would do that vexing protagonist justice.

*

Lee Fiora, Prep’s heroine, is a heartland daughter with her soul set on a tony East Coast boarding school.

We learn in the novel that she’s a white brunette with romantic notions. At school, she hopes to “meet a melancholy, athletic boy” who also likes reading and sweaters. But once Lee arrives at the austere Ault academy, a lot of that dreaminess goes right out the window.

It’s a tricky brief for a young actor. One has to drive a story, but from a passive place. My colleague McKayla Coyle pitched the up-and-coming Ella Rubin as a natural fit for the challenge.

Ella Rubin

Rubin previously wowed streaming audiences on Sterling Point from Amazon Prize, and has since stolen scenes in Sean Baker joints.

She’s generally captivating onscreen, but I think one of her performances captures Lee’s striver contradictions especially well. Her misguided student in thrall to Jay Duplass in The Chair is equally confused and assertive. Perfect Fiora recipe.

Alison Oliver

The Irish actress Alison Oliver sort of nailed the reserved, bookish, sweater-coveting sort in the Hulu adaptation of Sally Rooney’s Conversations with Friends.

There’s also a character rhyme. Just like Frances in Rooney’s novel, Lee has a cipher-y quality. She’s a beta to friends with larger personalities, inclined to flower the wall.

Oliver’s probably right at the edge of age appropriate, but I think she could capture Lee’s studious, stealthily magnetic nature. And some of that lust for life.

Abby Ryder Fortson

Abby Ryder Fortson is another vet of the adaptation trenches. She played the titular hero in 2023’s extremely tender, undersung Are You There God? It’s Me Margaret. And has the benefit of being closer to plausible as a freshman.

As Margaret, she conveyed a charming, wide-eyed bewilderment. And that antecedent to Lee was similarly concerned with style over substance. I think she’d kill it.

Fina Strazza

My final pitch is a theatre kid. Fina Strazza gave a wry, nervy performance on Broadway last year in Kimberly Belflower’s John Proctor is the Villain. She played a devout, Southern, public school student—which is is to say that her accent work is proven. And so is her angst.

Strazza would make a perfect Lee. Vulnerable, canny, and a little strange.

Now, who should play the imperious Gates Medkowski? Or that stressfully named lust object, Cross the lacrosse player? Only time will tell. Meantime, watch this space for more stunt-casting of mid-aughts fiction. (The Art of Fielding, anyone?)

Images via

More in Books

View All →

Leave a Reply