Thursday, November 19, 2026
Newsletter About
Opinion

Election Denialism Is All but Dead

Nearly six years after the attack on the Capitol, the Big Lie might finally be ebbing as a defining force in American politics.

This article was originally published by The Atlantic and is republished here under license.

Out of all the surprises of the 2026 midterm election, among the most heartening was Donald Trump’s willingness to accept the results. “We’ll probably work something out,” he told The New York Times of the incoming Democratic majority in Congress. The next day, he walked the press around the site of the planned White House ballroom, less interested in battling over the election than showing off his construction project.

This newfound tranquility did not last: In the weeks since the midterms, Trump has begun sharing posts on his Truth Social feed casting doubt on the integrity of the vote. “Does anybody really believe that this ‘Election’ was honest. How could the Polls be so wrong???” he asked on November 9. But a few stray posts on a bespoke social-media site are trifling compared with the aggressive campaign of propaganda, litigation, and brute force that Trump used to attempt to subvert the 2020 presidential vote. Six years after Trump launched the election-denialist movement, the Big Lie of election fraud might finally be ebbing as a defining force in American politics.

Kate Starbird, a University of Washington professor, monitored online election rumors in 2020 as they gained momentum. She has described the growth of election denialism that year as a dynamic of “participatory propaganda”—a feedback loop between political elites such as Trump, who seeded ideas about voter fraud, and the many Americans who responded to those suggestions by seeking out further evidence of supposed trickery. Through this process, what started with claims by Trump in the spring of 2020 about the supposed unreliability of mail-in ballots escalated into the attack on the Capitol on January 6. In the following years, election deniers continued to build their movement, taking positions as state and local election administrators and preparing to subvert—or, depending on your point of view, protect—the vote.

When Trump took power again in 2025, election denialism essentially became the official policy of the United States government. The FBI seized ballots from 2020 in Georgia’s Fulton County; the Justice Department demanded voter records from every state in the union, fueling theories that the voter rolls were riddled with inaccuracies; and, as the midterms grew closer, federal authorities grew more and more aggressive in seeking to shape the election in the GOP’s favor. Experts, election officials, and civil-society groups were wary that grassroots election deniers, together with the White House, might seek to upend either the voting process or the counting of ballots.

[Read: The election deniers are in retreat]

Yet many Republican candidates who had previously complained about rigged elections stayed quiet on the subject, perhaps worried that emphasizing claims of election fraud could push their supporters to stay home rather than vote. And as the magnitude of the Republican loss on Election Day became clear, election deniers remained similarly docile. Scott Perry, a Republican representative from Pennsylvania who drew the attention of federal prosecutors for his close involvement in the effort to overturn the 2020 election, conceded promptly to his Democratic challenger in remarks that emphasized the importance of “the peaceful transfer of authority that is paramount to our Republic.” Ali Alexander, a far-right activist and founder of the group Stop the Steal, which helped organize the rally at the Ellipse on January 6, 2021, released a statement on Telegram that “STOP THE STEAL SAYS MIDTERM WIPEOUT ELECTION WAS LEGITIMATE” and “WILL NOT PROTEST.”

As Election Day unfolded, Starbird told me, her team at the University of Washington’s Center for an Informed Public found that rumors of fraud didn’t gain the same traction as in 2020. When polls opened that morning, election workers in Westchester County, New York, discovered that voting machines were not properly scanning ballots—a logistical hiccup that generated conspiratorial online posts on both the left and right. The incident was similar to glitches in Arizona’s Maricopa County during the 2022 midterms, which grew into viral rumors of election fraud and became the focus of long-running complaints by Kari Lake, the GOP candidate who lost the Arizona governor’s race that year. Comparing posts on Twitter (now X) from both incidents, Starbird’s team found that “the overall content and attention around the events in Westchester was about 20 percent on Election Day as the attention around Maricopa,” Starbird said. In the days immediately after the vote, they continued to see only “very low” activity concerning election denial online.

At first, that quiet might have been attributable to Trump’s own apparent lack of interest in such conspiracies. Midterms typically occasion less public attention than presidential elections, and perhaps that was personally true for the president—who, unlike in 2020, was not on the ballot. In the absence of angry posts from the president, election deniers had little to coalesce around. Online interest in conspiracy theories increased once Trump started to dabble in his old fraud claims, Starbird told me, though still nowhere close to where it was in 2020. “They just don’t have all the ingredients they would need for a large-scale attempt to try to subvert election results,” she said.

The results themselves were arguably the biggest problem for any such attempt. The midterms were not just a Democratic victory but a total blowout—the biggest margin of House victory in a midterm for any party since the post-Watergate election of 1974. The resounding rejection of GOP governance left Republicans dejected, too stunned to attempt any unified subversion of the results. Major right-wing outlets such as Fox and Newsmax, which pushed election denial aggressively in 2020, did not attempt to rally the troops after 2026. “We’re seeing a few more activist journalists, people that work for hyperpartisan outlets, begin to play with this,” Starbird told me, but not “more mainstream conservative political voices.” After Trump shared speculation about rigged voting machines on Truth Social, the former Fox host Megyn Kelly posted on X, “Just stop.” Republican politicians, meanwhile, appear to have largely moved on to intraparty bickering.

[Jonathan Chait: The Left’s election denial]

MAGA may have been cannibalized in part by its own success. In 2020, Starbird has argued, the Big Lie thrived on the participation of true believers. In 2026, with the federal government itself promoting election denialism, those supporters were less inclined to take action themselves. “They were waiting for the Trump administration” to sweep in and seize ballots or otherwise save the day, Starbird told me. When Trump didn’t—because he had no power to do so—the grassroots was no longer primed to take action. On X, posts from right-wing influencers toying with the notion of a stolen election have accreted bitter comments. “Nothing will be done. It’s all a big dog and pony show. Sick of it,” complained the prominent Trump supporter @catturd2 in a Friday post, responding to a post from GOP Senator Ron Johnson casting doubt on election results in the Alaska Senate race.

Perhaps conspiracy theories of election fraud have just gotten old. Like a network television show renewed one too many times, the characters are stale, the plots familiar, the twists lacking surprise. When the election-denial movement first took off in the spring and summer of 2020, it was responding to circumstances that were genuinely novel—a global pandemic that necessitated a rapid shift toward mail-in balloting—and drawing on the crackling right-wing political energy of anti-mask and -lockdown protests. Six years later, that energy has dissipated. Trump himself is no longer a crusading outsider but a symbol of the stagnant political establishment that, a decade ago, he promised to upend. Election officials have worked hard to allay public fears about the integrity of the electoral process. People have different things on their minds, such as inflation and high gas prices caused by Trump’s war of choice in Iran. A half-decade-old story about Democrats stealing elections doesn’t speak to those concerns.

“The kind of widespread election denialism that undermines trust in democracy, that could be used and weaponized to contest election results—I’m hopeful that that is not as much of a threat going forward,” Starbird told me. Still, she emphasized that election lies are not entirely gone. “On the right, there is a deep story about how elections have been rigged against them in recent years,” she said. “And we may see another rigged-election narrative” arise in the future.

What that narrative will be, though, remains undetermined. As Trump’s power wanes, the Republican Party and the American far right, newly freed from his orbit, will be forced to search for new causes to rally around. Election fraud may no longer be among them.

More in Opinion

View All →

Leave a Reply