
Brookner was fifty-two (though she was soon to be ten years younger). She had a novel. She had an agent. Before long she would have a publisher. She was still teaching, and would be for some years to come, but she was changing her life. How did that happen? She told Anna Whitworth that she was writing a novel on her ancient typewriter to “fill the empty quarter,” up in her room at the Courtauld, when everyone else was away on their summer holidays. Whitworth, who knew that her friend suffered from depression, thought that novel-writing was her means of dealing with it. Brookner herself said as much, in interview after interview from the early 1980s onwards. She constructed a set-piece narrative. (This didn’t include a momentary “road not taken,” when, just after publishing David, she wrote to Chatto asking if she might write a Life of Mme de Staël: she would need a contract, as the job would involve living in Switzerland for a while. No, they replied, it wasn’t commercial enough.) She always said that when she started writing her first novel she was experiencing sadness, desperation and boredom, to the point of being “endangered.” She was “unhappy” and “alone” and “she wanted to know how she had deserved such a fate.” There was “a gap,” a lack of “structure” in her life, a need to “fill the time.”
She is never specific about details, of course, but reaching her fifties without family or children, the shock and disappointment of the Blunt scandal, her hidden feelings for MacLehose, the end of her work on David, and her increasing feeling of alienation from the way art history was being taught, all contributed to her sense of being “endangered.” By the mid-1980s she has polished this into a well-shaped, gripping story:
I started writing [fiction] because of a terrible feeling of powerlessness: I felt I was drifting and obscure, and I rebelled against that. I didn’t see what I could do to change my condition. I wanted to control rather than be controlled, to ordain rather than be ordained, and to relegate rather than be relegated.
She talked about her difficult childhood, the sadness of her parents, the burden of looking after them and the grief of their loss, her loneliness and her childlessness. Her first novel, she said, was “a reckoning.” She wrote it “to exorcise a painful experience.” She was impelled by “boredom and the wish to review my life, which seemed to be drifting in predictable channels.” “I could have got very sorry for myself and miserable, but it seemed such a waste of time to do that, and I’d always got a lot of nourishment from fiction.” Sometimes she related her feelings to her professional life: “I think I was getting stale as a teacher and I knew retirement was looming.” “There aren’t many chances for taking a risk in art history.”
However sympathetic, scathing or evasive Brookner was about psychoanalysis, her novels take her, and her readers, deep into the repressed, into worlds of trauma and of dreams.
She began as an “idle experiment.” She had never thought of writing fiction before but had always admired fiction writers and wondered if she could do it.
I didn’t think I could. I just wrote a page, the first page, and nobody seemed to think it was wrong. An angel with a flaming sword didn’t appear and say, “You shouldn’t be doing this.” So I wrote another page, and another, and at the end of the summer, I had a story. That’s all I wanted to do—tell a story.
Once she had started, on she went. She wrote at speed. “There were no secret notebooks, not a scrap, not a sentence…no drafts…no false starts: there simply isn’t the time.” She would always follow the same pattern. Every novel would be written in three months, at first because it was the length of the summer vacation. Later, she switched to the winter months, but the writing never took much longer than that. She knew what the ending would be. She mapped the book out in her head while walking, and then wrote it straight into a notebook, as though it had been “encoded in the unconscious.” She wrote either on unlined A4 pads from Ryman stationers or in “Europa” ring-bound notebooks, lined or criss-crossed, with brightly colored covers.
The pages were densely written, with few signs of corrections, sometimes switching from the novel in progress to the current review she was working on. She then typed these up herself, or used a typist (who would have had to be a gifted reader of difficult handwriting). While working on David in 1979, she told MacLehose that it had been “resplendently typed by Rosalind, a fierce girl with red hair whose spelling is slightly better than mine.” Much later, in 1996, she mentioned to the publisher at Cape, Tom Maschler, that she had found a quick, efficient new typist. One of her first copyeditors at Cape, a young English graduate, was struck by the near-perfect state of the submitted typescript. Once she had marked it up, she would go to Brookner’s flat and work through the comments with her. Brookner treated her with great politeness but was very firm on stylistic points: she knew what she wanted. Not much was changed, and their work together was finished very briskly.
The outcome of this process was astonishingly polished. Hilary Mantel, a great admirer, put it well: “When her first novel was published in 1981 she seemed to have arrived perfectly formed, as if she had hatched from a marble egg.”
The phrase “encoded in the unconscious” teasingly opens the door to psychoanalytical explanations. She was open with some interviewers about having had “quite long periods of depression,” but added that she found depression nourishing and creative. So, she was often asked, was writing fiction a form of therapy? To which she would reply: “If it were therapy I wish it had worked. It doesn’t work that way, which is why I have to keep on doing it.” She was adamant about not having been in psychoanalysis: “No, and I wouldn’t do it now, it would take too long,” she told an interviewer in 1985, and again, much later, in 2009: “She has always admired Freud, but has resisted any temptation to undergo psychoanalysis. ‘It wasn’t within my scope. And one doesn’t know how intelligent the interrogator would be.’” But elsewhere, she said that finishing her first novel was like ending analysis: “When it was over, it was over, like coming away from a psychoanalytical session; you left it behind.” More than once, she talked of that novel “as a little exercise in self-analysis. What is interesting about self-analysis is that it leads nowhere. It is an art-form in itself.” The parallel between fiction-writing and analysis recurred: “In a sense, what I’m doing is to neutralize my experience. Freud said that the drama of transformation is to change powerful feelings into weak ones.”
She often gives out mixed signals on the subject, referring to “we Freudian analysts” in her 1983 review of Norman Bryson’s work, or praising Anthony Clare’s 1984 book of his television interviews, In the Psychiatrist’s Chair, where she compares some of his interviewees to “characters in fiction whom the author has not fully worked out.” She told an ex-student once, in a dry and incredulous tone, that a friend of hers (very probably Lisl Klein), whose family had perished in the Holocaust, was telling the analyst about this, and the analyst started to cry. Her friend apologized for the terrible things she was having to talk about, and the analyst said, “No, it’s not that, my dog has just died.” But however sympathetic, scathing or evasive Brookner was about psychoanalysis, her novels take her, and her readers, deep into the repressed, into worlds of trauma and of dreams.
She prefers to describe fiction-writing, not as therapy or auto-biography, but as a strange process of remembering. She was proud of having a “superb” memory, but many things she didn’t know that she remembered started to surface when she began to write novels. Writing was a process of discovering things “I didn’t know were there, that had lain in the unconscious for a very long time.” So she couldn’t have written novels at thirty: there had to be time for those things to surface. Writing fiction, she said strangely and beautifully, was “trying very hard to remember something which has not yet taken place.”
She prefers to describe fiction-writing, not as therapy or auto-biography, but as a strange process of remembering.
Were these novels, then, autobiographical? everyone asked. In early interviews, she firmly denied it. She was not her first heroine, “not at all.” Apart from the description of her room in Paris, everything else in her first novel was “totally invented.” Later, she became less defensive. In 1985: “A lot of me must be in them. Yes—aspirations, longings, desires, sadnesses, too. I don’t think I give hostages to fortune in admitting that much.” In 1987, to her Paris Review interviewer Shusha Guppy, who asked her if her first novel was autobiographical, she replied: “It was.” She didn’t mean—as many readers would have liked her to mean—that her novels were romans-à-clef, which could be mapped straight on to events and characters in her own life. But she did mean that the sources of their emotions were profoundly personal. This long, tantalizing, double performance of self-revelation and self-disguise began with the title, and the wickedly challenging first sentence, of A Start in Life: “Dr Weiss, at forty, knew that her life had been ruined by literature.”
In 1980, Brookner’s entry in Who’s Who described her as Reader at the Courtauld Institute, born in 1928. In 1981, the year A Start in Life was published, it described her as “Professor” Anita Brookner, Reader at the Courtauld, born in 1938. So now, all of a sudden, she was forty-three. This deliberate decision to get herself ready for a new start in life would come back to bite her.
She didn’t find a publisher for her new novel straight away. MacLehose read it and took it to his editor-in-chief at Collins, the urbane and conservative biographer Philip Ziegler, who said it was quite out of the question for the Collins list, they couldn’t possibly sell it. If she was disappointed, she didn’t let MacLehose know—and he felt she was completely confident that she would place it somewhere. At that point Mark Hamilton took over, and sent it to one or two other publishers, including Jonathan Cape. Cape was then run by two forceful characters, Tom Maschler and Graham C. Greene. Liz Calder was the other main editor (she had moved to Cape from Gollancz in 1979). She had lived in New Zealand and Brazil before settling in England, and she was a shrewd, ambitious publisher, as well as a glamorous and sympathetic person. She was creating her own distinctive list (including Salman Rushdie and Julian Barnes) within the firm, but had to run her choices past Maschler. Calder received what she described as a very downbeat letter from Hamilton. It read:
Dear Liz, I wonder if Anita Brookner’s novel A Start in Life might be something for you? The writer is a lecturer at the Courtauld Institute and has written several books on late 18th century art…I will be intrigued to hear what you think of this novel.
Calder, herself intrigued, gave it to one of Cape’s freelance “readers” for a first judgement. This reader was Nicola Beauman, later the publisher of Persephone Books. She took so violently against it—as in, it’s a book about very grey people in a very grey place—that Calder decided to take another look. She loved it. She also sent it to another of Cape’s readers, Sally Sampson, who was very enthusiastic. Calder had then to persuade Maschler, who wasn’t especially keen. It was generally the case, Calder remembered, that he would take the contrary view to hers. She felt there was some jealousy and rivalry there. But she persuaded him. She didn’t think it would be a bestseller, but she felt that the writing was “extraordinary: you knew this was a writer and would go on being so.” The contract gave Brookner an advance of £750, with 10 per cent royalties, and a print run of 1,500 copies. She com-plained, mildly, about the cover photograph, which she thought made her look “like a faithful hound.” In the States, it was published by Simon & Schuster, who to Calder’s disapproval renamed it The Debut: but Brookner didn’t argue with that.
They started, and continued, their working relationship with lunch at L’Étoile in Charlotte Street. A regular pattern was at once established. When Calder arrived, Brookner was already there, quietly waiting. They would talk not so much about her book as about Calder’s latest news. When they first met, Calder’s life was in upheaval; she had just begun her own new start, in her forties, with the person who would be her long-term partner. She told Brookner that she had fallen in love. The reply came: “Well, it’s all there is, Liz.” In interviews, when Brookner was asked (as she often was): “Do you think you will go on writing about love?” she replied: “What else is there? Everything else is merely literature.”
______________________________

From Anita Brookner: Art and Life by Hermione Lee. Copyright © 2026. Available from Alfred A. Knopf, an imprint of Knopf Doubleday Publishing Group, a division of Penguin Random House, LLC.
Leave a Reply