Tuesday, November 17, 2026
Newsletter About
Books

On Brian Blanchfield’s Proxies and the Respite of Queer Stories

In 2018, a new friend of mine gave me Brian Blanchfield’s Proxies with a knowing smile and a promise that I would love it. I have to admit here that this friend and I were in the early dances of

This article was originally published by Literary Hub and is republished here under license.

typewriter

In 2018, a new friend of mine gave me Brian Blanchfield’s Proxies with a knowing smile and a promise that I would love it. I have to admit here that this friend and I were in the early dances of a mutual crush. This is, after all, the known gifting language of any good lesbian. Give them a book filled with a spiraling narrator searching equally for knowledge and failure; give them a book filled with the gritty details of hands-free sex, even the slightest attempt at defining scissoring, a book that states, ‘We fucked, some of us, a feeling of fucking, felt for the feeling in one another, and got off on it.’

I went into Proxies blindly and of course the trick worked. Later my new friend and I would go on to make out in a snowy cab ride home, after lingering too long over glasses of orange wine at Molasses Books. But more than the queer desire that quietly colors Proxies, what captivated me most about Blachfield’s third book was his ability to weave between genre with little care for establishing parameters for his reader. Or was he able to weave between genre because of his transparency in parameters? Either way I shook it, the book read like an assured contradiction to itself. Blanchfield’s writing existed solely for his own sake. Simultaneously, it seemed to be laying new ground for how a memoir should behave.

Told through 24 short essays, Proxies combines autobiography with apparently arbitrary interest points. First published in January 2016, each essay tests the limits of writing the self. Blachfield sets out always with purpose and yet his starting point inevitably fails to contain him, whether in topic or genre. Between talking owls, housesitting, frottage (that pesky task of defining gay sex), the collection of ‘essays near knowing’ swings comfortably between the floral language of a seasoned poet and the straight-forward tones of a memoirist; it balances academic touchpoints and whole cultural remembrances. While the prose may read as an unorganized stream of consciousness, or as Blanchfield notes in the book’s preface, ‘a concession to imprecision, a failure’, each essay is tediously framed: a topic is announced and a subheader follows, always reading ‘Permitting shame, Error and Guilt, Myself the Single Source’. Then the unspooling begins.

Proxies entered the scene at the front of the first Trump administration. Ten years later, as we find ourselves in the second administration, queer rights are still being eroded at breakneck speed, and the text remind a pivotal reminder to queer archive.

In her 2017 review of Proxies, Claire Lowdon laments that this repetition atop the page “becomes mantra, then superstition, then OCD-style neurosis.” She notes that Blachfield “is forcibly staking out territory for himself and declaring it a safe space. It doesn’t work like that. You have to earn it.”

This particular frame of [subject announcement, subheader, and body of exploration] is crucial to the book’s authority. But Blachfield is not out to convince anyone that his story is true nor factually correct. Rather, Proxies and each frame within breaks the many contracts of memoir.

Yes, Blachfield is a lone authority here but he is a faulty one; he states this up front. With error in his favor, his story is not told as truth but as memory best recalled. Unlike traditional memoir where the object of the form is to tell the story of what happened, Blachfield insists on witness rather than testimony. He is a witness to remembering his past and he invites the reader to join him in discovery in real-time. He reserves his ability to check facts and his memory in a chapter that remains separate from the rest of the essays, aptly titled ‘Corrections’, laid out in the back of the book and after he has wrung out his topics in full. The separation of his own telling and the facts-of-it-all renders the factuality nearly irrelevant. He has built a form of truth through processing. That genre does not contain him only makes his authority worthwhile.

Proxies does not claim to even be a memoir. It chooses a different language for itself.

In ‘On Reset,’ Blanchfield quotes Gertrude Stein in her assertion that ‘repetition is never exact repetition, because the human registering it is different the second time’. If the reader does indeed take the time to return to each title, subtitle, and frame within Proxies, each time Blanchfield circles back to a mundane topic the reader and writer alike seemingly become electrified at the possibility of error; the pressure to be ‘accurate’ simultaneously becomes so maddening and casual that it nearly dissolves.

Proxies entered the scene at the front of the first Trump administration. Ten years later, as we find ourselves in the second administration, queer rights are still being eroded at breakneck speed, and the text remind a pivotal reminder to queer archive. But beyond its themes, Proxies sets an early example of how writing with an eye towards error is not only a critical mode of rebellion but a step closer to a truer version of memoir.

These days, the publishing industry seems to be watching the collapse of itself and this is especially applicable for memoirs. Memoirs, along with general nonfiction, are not selling well. While lack of sales is of course tethered to a shifting publishing landscap—media outlets and publishing houses alike are folding, reading is now aesthetic, attention spans have condensed to one minute clips, no one is paying writers, everyone is shouting about the literary crisis—I’ll argue that part of the collapse is publishing’s resistance to move away from marketing tactics that previously served memoir well.

Proxies does not claim to even be a memoir. It chooses a different language for itself. But returning to the text in a time where believability is threatened on a daily basis, the book gives me great comfort as my own genre-blurry debut enters the world.  It is a reminder that queer stories have always been respite to formulaic failures and it gives me hope that queer writers will continue to hold Proxies as not only a hot gift-giving resource but also as a secret handshake in what is possible within understanding ourselves, as individuals and amongst the greater good, that to read within quieter and less pronounced narratives is as worthwhile an endeavor as any splashy memoir sticking to the charts.

And as Blanchfield states so sweetly, in closing out his makeshift autobiography, “Our first date was on Election Day, 2010. …we kissed in the beams, which made the little globes on the ghostery bush galactic. We mark our anniversary out from there, and we tell everyone every year we re-elect each other. Campaign comes from the Latin campus. Open country. And country from contra. All the area out in front of you, facing you. No term limits. The queer heart.”

__________________________________

Nanny Nanny

Nanny Nanny by K Chiucarello is available from Ecco.

More in Books

View All →

Leave a Reply